Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Abort What You Think You Know


I read an on-line article today about a woman in the UK who chose to abort her son because she was told he had Down Syndrome and a host of other health problems. I would never judge anyone for terminating a pregnancy as I am Pro-Choice but I had immediate feelings of sorrow for her. I feel sorry for what she is missing and what she really has lost. She should have aborted her pre-conceived notions about Down Syndrome and what the "professionals" (who likely have no children with Down Syndrome or first hand knowledge) told her and her husband. I applaud her courage to share her story and images with the insensitive masses and open up to ridicule. I wonder what her reasoning was to come forward now during Down Syndrome awareness month and have to question the plug for the agency that helped her. The Antenatal Results and Choices (ARC) who she will be soon running a marathon for.

Based on her carefully crafted language she and her husband seem like a loving pair who have done their best to rationalize their decision of terminating Oscar's (yes they named him) life before they had a chance to meet him. They claimed his heart condition boasted a 1% survival rate. Maybe this is what pushed her to the decision of termination in conjunction with her fear of having a "poorly child with Down Syndrome"? or it was their feat of judgement of him? or their lack of knowledge? I wouldn't want to speculate. She claims to have received support for her decision as opposed to being met with opposition in general. This was also a really sad part of her story and a reflection of how our society as a whole views Down Syndrome. She implies that people understand why she would terminate a baby with Down Syndrome and it is more accepted than aborting a "perfect" or "typical" baby.

My son isn't typical but he is perfect.
This being Down Syndrome awareness month I feel it is an excellent time to start a dialogue about professionals and how they deliver diagnosis and information to emotional, vulnerable, terrified parents and how this information and its delivery impact their decision's and lives.

In her article she notes that approximately 3 abortions a day in the UK take place because of a Down Syndrome diagnosis. I would love to know how many are based on FEAR of the unknown due to the inaccurate information provided by their health care professionals, who after all are just people too.

We blindly put our faith in these people as once we enter a health care facility it is as if we loose all common sense and revert to placing blind faith into the hands of our intelligent, over achieving peers who achieved a higher education than us and dedicated their lives to their profession for whatever reason. 
In the US physicians and physicians assistants take the traditional Hippocratic Oath, with one major cornerstone being "First do no harm". Is failing to provide accurate and/or current information to parents harmful? I will say YES! With 1 in 691 births in the USA one would assume that more attention would be paid by health care professionals to update their information on this not-so-rare chromosomal issue.

I can speak from experience the devastation that a poorly and thoughtlessly delivered diagnosis does to a mother. My son Blake was born with Down Syndrome in 2011 and we has no prior knowledge or even risk. Our ultrasound, like my daughters was clean with no physical "markers" for Down Syndrome, I was under the age of 35 and declined genetic testing and deemed it unnecessary as I would have had Blake no matter what testing revealed.  When he was born he came in a dramatic fashion and spent 6 days in the special care nursery with issues unrelated to Down Syndrome. The Doctor's suspected he had  Down Syndrome because of the shape of his eyes. This was the only physical characteristic seen at birth, no simian crease, no low set ears, neck issues, heart issues, etc.
They took his blood and told us we have to wait about two weeks. They (Doctors/Nurses) also gave us some cliche, bullshit, information about people with Down Syndrome. Reciting stereotypes and things you hear from random people. No congratulations or the excitement that I received when my daughter was born. Just solemn faces and lots of "doom and gloom". I was given generic resources to call but never anything REAL about people with Down Syndrome. A lot of "we don't know" and "Everyone is different" and all the things that could happen that would be considered negative, wrong or a struggle for us. I received NONE of "People with Down Syndrome live productive lives" "People with Down Syndrome are living into their 60's and beyond" "People with Down Syndrome have jobs, relationships, go to college and have happy lives".  You can imagine a hormonal, post-partum mothers terror as I am reaching to the only trusted people that are there, the ones who are supposed to be all powerful and knowledgeable, the Doctors and medical staff! When Blake's doctor did give me his final diagnosis I had brought Blake into the office at two weeks of age for his circumcision. When I politely asked the Doctor, "So... Did Blake's test come back"? His reply "Oh, you didn't get my voicemail?" I was in shock and said "Obviously not or I wouldn't be asking" and he replied" Oh yeah he has it" and promptly got up from his chair to go check the other room for foreskin removal prep. The doctor left me hysterically bawling my eyes out in my husbands arms.

Oh yeah he has it? Seriously? A diagnosis left on a voice mail? A diagnosis so thoughtlessly given to me with no compassion or care. He had very little answers for me and in a follow up frantic phone call I had more information than he did about Down Syndrome and the different types from a simple Google search.

I always wondered who the person was who received the news of Blake's extra chromosome on their voice mail. They probably felt sorry for whomever was supposed to receive it as I'm sure that message was not much better than the one we had live.

I wonder if this woman's decision would have changed if she would have had a chance to talk with me or another mother who is actually living with a son with Down Syndrome. Ultrasounds and Doctors can be wrong, remember mine that said Blake had ZERO markers and Down Syndrome was a non issue .... maybe the same was true about her child's "1% chance of survival"?

I also want to point out that Blake has been a treasure to his siblings, not something that takes time away from them. He can be the bratty little brother too like any other kid but by-and-large they all like playing together and including Blake. We have an age range in our house of 16,12,6,3 who all require attention from us. As parents you juggle and "make it work", having a child with Down Syndrome is not a detriment to your other children.

Blake is many things, a son, brother, nephew and grandson. He is now a student in an inclusive pre-school with peers and friends. He is an inspiration to me personally and impacts the lives of all of the people he comes in contact with. He is also a little stubborn contrarian who is self directed and knows what he wants. He is funny and loves to dance. He is a rough-and-tumble, sensory seeking boy. He is MY SON, perfectly imperfect.



I want to offer the mother a lifetime of compassionate condolence that she will need while forever missing the beautiful baby she didn't want to take the chance on. I'm sorry for her fear and her grief. I'm going to kiss my son now and celebrate that he is not a generic, 'typical' child. I will celebrate how exciting our lives are now as we just don't know what Blake will do or achieve next, just like our other kids. I will happily accept the extra work, sleepless nights, stress and worry that comes with the title of "Mother". I feel fortunate that life forced me into changing my perspective and gave me the opportunity to be a part of the Down Syndrome community.  She should have aborted the ideas and stereotypes she thought she knew, instead of Oscar.  Again, I respect a woman's right to choose, I just hope she had the accurate information when making her choice. If she truly did I think her decision may have been different.
My husband, Blake and I

I would love to be a resource for other mother's who are contemplating this decision and be available to share my experience. The Antenatal Results and Choices (ARC) organization's mission is "We believe that every parent should have access to non-directive information and support through antenatal testing and its consequences"
I would be open to providing the parents support so they gain access to ALL the information from a person directly dealing with someone who has Down Syndrome, not a chart, graph, or medical statistics and what "could" happen.  I would like toadd that there are MANY positive "consequences" to having a child with Down Syndrome. NO ONE KNOWS what a child will do or not do but the child. It is up to you to decide if you are willing to live with the "What if" based on tests ans stats alone or instead accept your child for all of his/her uniqueness and embrace your new reality.

I would be happy to consult with ANY mother at ANY time.

Image by: Tamara Wickstrom

13 comments:

  1. Your little man is precious. My little man was born with Down syndrome in 2008. We celebrate him daily! What a joy we would have missed if he were not in our liveS!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Awesomely well put! Love love my little piglet....we will not let down syndrome define her. ♡♡

    ReplyDelete
  3. Beautiful!!! Thank you for writing such a beautiful response to Suzanne's post! You hit on almost everything I'd like to share as well. We adopted an incredible little boy with DS from Ethiopia last summer. Cannot imagine life without him... blessing beyond compare! Would do it again in a heartbeat. Oh, and our other four children would all agree... it's been one of the best decisions we've ever made as a family!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well written. Thank you. I found out when I was 21 weeks pregnant, 15 years ago that our first daughter would be born with Down Syndrome. I was given a lot of sympathy and a lot of bad information but luckily I had a great OB that immediately connected us to "Gages" family. He was 16 and our doctor had delivered him too. We met Gage and I instantly fell in love with him and his family. I knew we made the right choice to keep our little girl. She amazes me all the time and is so sassy. I know how much she has changed me for the better. I feel sad that women have to make these choices but I will never let my daughter think she is anything less than the beautiful gift she has been to me.

    Thank you for sharing your story.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for sharing your story. My daughter is today 20, I was 23 I gave birth to her. They took our daughter away, didn't told us anything, we saw our daughter hour later AFTER we've been told that they had to do Some tests and that we have to be prepare to see her, because she was à " Mongool" (translate=retarded) THE doctor who Said this, à woman, told us before we even had looked at our daughter that THE baby was handicapted. They never congrutaleted us. AFTER 5 long minutes Some nurse came in THE room with THE baby asking IF I wanted to hold my baby. Within 1 second my husband took THE baby grom her and tel her to leave THE room. Our baby was THE most perfect baby I ever seen, she was and is today stil pur sunshine!! Those doctors knew nothing about Down Syndrome, they gave us the feeling that this child would never be able to do anything. We didn't know for 9 months and after birth, the longest hour of Our live, we thought - we cried- we really thought that something very wrong was going in with Our baby. We knew when we finally hold her that nothing was wrong with her, we just knew. Before this moment we didn't knew anything about Down Syndrome and we didn't have Google like today!! Our family and friends helped us with everything. In the first two years we visit the hospital monthly to make sure everything was OK with Our beautiful daughter Anais. everytime that we was on consult seeing different doctors they asked the same question: what is wrong? Till today nothing is wrong with Anais, she is Our sunshine - she do not have any medical history, any health issues at all. We have also to youngest daughters, 12 and 6. Both pregnancy we testen on Down Syndrome, but just for us to know before Birth. Never ever we die the test for another reason.

    I am just saying thank you for your story. Blessings for you, your husband and your beautiful son Blake

    From à happy family @holland

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great writing. Well said on all points. I, too was delivered the news jn a less than sensitive way. A dr. I had never met came into my post birth room some 8 hrs later with a piece of paper that stated down syndrome at the top. He handed it to me, stood across from my hospital bed, arms folded and rested his body against the wall, waiting for "the reaction" I suppose. Well, he got one. We were unprepared for this news. But, now deep in the past, the news and how we received it is at the bottom of the ocean, as we now celebrate the life of my son who is a true God given blessing to my family. I, too, could speak to a mother contemplating a decision to abort and would make her spend time with my son. Your son is gorgeous by the way and the pictures shared above are orecious!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Love this Lisa! Always straight up and straight from the heart! Blake is a wonderful, handsome little man! He has an amazing family! U guys r so positive and sound so happy! Love all the articles u write and pictures u post. Xo

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for youre article I too have a child with DS. she is 34 happy active, social, personable, loving, full of life, with a mind of her own. She is a light to many in our small Utah town. She was mainstreamed in school and was fully accepted by her classmates. Her social life is full and she is in a program with her peers , she is involved in Special Olympics and attends church with us, where she is a part of the religious family. I cannot say it has been a journey without difficulties, but it has been a journey that I would take over again, I love my girl with all my heart.

    ReplyDelete
  9. When I was only 10 weeks pregnant, I agreed to the blood test and only did that because I was "encouraged" due to my age being 35. They said she tested high for having Ds and then they wanted an amnio to confirm. Confirm what? Even though they reminded me visit after visit that I could end this pregnancy and still have time to "try again". I told them countless times that Ds is not a deciding factor to end my daughter's life! She is only 5 months old and I know we have much to learn but my "tour guide" amazes me daily. Thanks for your article... helpful information is better than one sided opinions. My doctors never helped with unbiased info, I read alot and was prepared for whatever happened!

    ReplyDelete
  10. God bless you Lisa. You are amazing and your family is beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Love your story & thank you for sharing it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My daughter Kari is a perfect daughter to me and my husband,
    she is a perfect little sister to my two daughters,
    she is the perfect big sister to her brother.

    Love your story,
    thank you for writting

    ReplyDelete
  13. A gift from God. We too have a son now 31 who has DS. He is a blessing to us, loved by all his brothers and sisters and made us many new, true friends. I wasn't told he had DS until the day after he was born, but my husband was told the night before as he was leaving the hospital and they told him he didn't have to take him home as he had DS. My husband was horrified and said that he was his son, having DS made no difference. We were told the next day that he would be a cabbage and never do anything or be able to walk etc. he loves riding, carriage driving and cycling on his trike.

    ReplyDelete